ACTFL Proficiency Guidelines - Writing

Superior

Advanced

ADVANCED HIGH
ADVANCED MID
ADVANCED LOW

Intermediate

INTERMEDIATE HIGH
INTERMEDIATE MID
INTERMEDIATE LOW

Novice

NOVICE HIGH
NOVICE MID
NOVICE LOW

Back to LTI Home


SUPERIOR

Writers at the Superior level are able to write most kinds of correspondence, such as memos and letters, as well as summaries, reports, and research papers on a variety of practical, social, academic or professional topics treated both abstractly and concretely. They demonstrate the ability to explain complex matters in detail, provide lengthy narrations in all time frames and aspects, present opinion, develop persuasive arguments based on logic, and construct extended hypotheses and conjectures. They can organize ideas clearly, the relationship of ideas is consistently clear, showing chronological ordering, logical ordering, cause and effect, comparison, and thematic development, but their writing may not totally reflect target language cultural, syntactic, and structural patterns. They demonstrate full control of structures, both general and specialized/professional vocabulary, spelling or symbol production, cohesive devices, and punctuation except for occasional errors that may occur, particularly in low-frequency structures, but that do not interfere with comprehension and rarely disturb the native reader. Their vocabulary is precise and varied with frequent use of synonyms. The length of writing at this level extends from a number of paragraphs to a number of pages. To supplement specialized vocabulary or to improve content and style, superior-level writers use dictionaries and other resources with a high degree of accuracy. They are aware of formal and informal styles of writing in which format, salutations, and style conform to cultural standards and writing etiquette. They use a variety of sentence structures, syntax, and vocabulary to tailor their writing to various purposes or readers.

Back to Top

ADVANCED

ADVANCED HIGH

ADVANCED MID

ADVANCED LOW

ADVANCED HIGH

ADVANCED HIGH - Writers at the Advanced-High level are able to write about a variety of topics with significant precision and detail. They can handle most social and informal business correspondence using conventional greetings, openings, and closings. They can write extensively about topics relating to particular interests and special areas of competence, but tend to emphasize the concrete aspects of such topics. Advanced-High level writers can describe and narrate in all major time frames, with good control of aspect, and show the ability to develop arguments and construct hypotheses, but have some difficulty dealing with topics in abstract, global, and/or impersonal terms. Advanced-High level writers incorporate many of the features of the Superior level, but cannot sustain them. They often show remarkable ease of expression, but under the demands of Superior-level writing tasks, time constraints, and pressure, patterns of error appear. They have good control of a full range of grammatical structures and a fairly wide general vocabulary but cannot yet use them comfortably and accurately all the time. Weaknesses in grammar, vocabulary, or in spelling or character writing formation may occasionally distract the native reader from the message. Writers do not consistently demonstrate flexibility to vary their style according to different tasks and readers. Their writing production will often read rather successfully on the surface but will fail to convey adequately the subtlety, nuance, and/or required details of writing.

Back to Top

ADVANCED MID

ADVANCED MID - Writers at the Advanced-Mid level are able to meet a range of work and/or academic writing needs with fullness and cohesiveness; to write cohesive summaries; to write about familiar topics relating to interests and events of current, public, and personal relevance by means of narratives and descriptions of a factual nature. Advanced-Mid level writers demonstrate the ability to narrate and describe with some detail in all major time frames. Written expression is characterized by a range of general vocabulary that expresses thoughts clearly, at times supported by some paraphrasing or elaboration. Writing at the Advanced-Mid level may exhibit a number of cohesive devices, in producing texts of several paragraphs in length. There is good control of the most frequently used syntactic structures, e.g., common word order patterns, coordination, subordination. There may be frequent errors in complex sentences, as well as in punctuation, spelling, or the formation of nonalphabetic symbols and character production due to graphic or sound confusion. While features of the written style of the target language may be present, Advanced-Mid level writing may at times resemble transcriptions of oral discourse. Where appropriate, Advance-Mid writing incorporates organizational elements such as introduction, topic sentences, supporting facts, comparing and contrasting, chronological sequencing, summary, and conclusion. When called on to perform functions or to handle topics associated with the Superior level, the Advanced-Mid writers will generally manifest a decline in the quality and/or quantity of their writing, often lacking the rhetorical structure, the accuracy, and the fullness of elaboration and detail that would characteristic of the Superior level. Writing at the Advanced-Mid level is understood readily by natives not used to the writing of non-natives.

Back to Top

ADVANCED LOW

Writers at the Advanced-Low level are able to meet basic work and/or academic writing needs, produce routine social correspondence, write about familiar topics by means of narratives and descriptions of a factual nature, and write cohesive summaries. Advanced-Low writing reflects the ability to combine and link sentences into texts of paragraph length and structure. Their accounts, while adequate, may not be substantive. Writers at the Advanced-Low level demonstrate an ability to write with a limited number of cohesive devices, and may resort to much redundancy, and awkward repetition. Use of dependent clauses is present and structurally coherent, while it often reflects the writer’s native language or patterns. Writing at the Advanced-Low level may resemble native language patterns of oral discourse. More often than not, the vocabulary, grammar, and style are essentially reflective of informal writing. Writers demonstrate sustained control of simple target-language sentence structures and partial control of more complex structures. While attempting to perform functions at the Superior level, their writing will deteriorate significantly. Writing at the Advanced-Low level is understood by natives not used to the writing of non-natives.

Back to Top

INTERMEDIATE

INTERMEDIATE HIGH

INTERMEDIATE MID

INTERMEDIATE LOW

INTERMEDIATE HIGH

INTERMEDIATE HIGH - Writers at the Intermediate-High level are able to meet all practical writing needs such as taking rather detailed notes on familiar topics, writing uncomplicated letters, summaries, and essays related to work, school experiences, and topics of current, general interest. They can also write simple descriptions and narrations of paragraph length on everyday events and situations in different time frames, although with some inaccuracies and inconsistencies. Intermediate-High writers connect sentences into paragraphs using basic cohesive elements, but with some breakdown in one or more features of the Advanced level. They are often successful in their use of paraphrase and elaboration. In those languages that use verbal markers to indicate tense and aspect, forms are not consistently accurate. The vocabulary, grammar, and style of Intermediate-High writers are essentially reflective of the spoken language. Their writing, even with numerous but not significant errors, is generally comprehensible to natives not used to the writing of non-natives.

Back to Top

INTERMEDIATE MID

Writers at the Intermediate-Mid level are able to meet a number of practical writing needs. They can write short, simple letters, essays, and descriptions in loosely connected text that are based on personal preferences, daily routines, common events, and other topics related to personal experiences and immediate surroundings. Most writing is framed in present time, with inconsistent references to other time frames. There is some evidence (although minimal) of the use of grammatical and stylistic cohesive elements — object pronouns, relative pronouns, adverbs of time, coordinating conjunctions, and subordinate clauses. The writing style is reflective of the grammar and lexicon of spoken language. Writers at the Intermediate-Mid level show evidence of the control of the syntax in non-complex sentences and in basic verb forms, such as declensions or conjugations. Writing is best defined as a collection of discrete sentences, since there is little evidence of deliberate organization. Intermediate-mid writers can be readily understood by natives used to the writing of non-natives.

Back to Top

INTERMEDIATE LOW

INTERMEDIATE LOW - Writers at the Intermediate-Low level are able to meet some limited practical writing needs. They can create statements and formulate questions based on familiar material. Most sentences are recombinations of learned vocabulary and structures. These are short and simple conversational-style sentences with basic subject-verb-object word order. They are written mostly in present time with occasional and often incorrect uses of past or future time. Writing tends to be a collection of simple sentences loosely strung together, often with repetitive structure. Vocabulary is limited to common objects and routine activities, adequate to express elementary needs. Writing is somewhat mechanistic and topics are limited to highly predictable content areas and personal information tied to limited language experience. There may be basic errors in grammar, word choice, punctuation, spelling, and in the formation and use of nonalphabetic symbols. Their writing is understood by natives used to the writing of non-natives.

Back to Top

 

NOVICE

NOVICE HIGH

NOVICE MID

NOVICE LOW

NOVICE HIGH

NOVICE HIGH - Writers at the Novice-high level are able to meet limited un-complicated practical writing needs, such as lists, short messages, postcards, and simple notes, and to express familiar meanings by relying mainly on memorized material, limited by the context in which the language was learned. They are able to recombine learned vocabulary and structures to create simple sentences on very familiar topics, but the language they produce may only partially communicate what is intended. Due to a lack of adequate vocabulary and/or control of the language features of the Intermediate level, the writing is generally writer-centered and focuses on common, discrete elements of daily life. Their writing is generally comprehensible to natives used to the writing of non-natives.

Back to Top

NOVICE MID

NOVICE MID - Writers at the Novice-Mid level are able to copy or transcribe familiar words or phrases, and reproduce from memory a modest number of isolated words and phrases. Novice-Mid writers exhibit a high degree of accuracy when writing using prompts based on a well-practiced, familiar topic and a linguistic repertoire focused at this level. With less familiar topics, there is a marked decrease in accuracy. There is little evidence of functional writing skills. They can supply limited information on simple forms and documents, and other simple biographical information, such as names, numbers, and nationality. Errors in spelling or in the representation of symbols may be frequent. Their writing may be difficult to understand even by those accustomed to reading the writing of non-natives.

Back to Top

NOVICE LOW

NOVICE LOW - Writers at the Novice-Low level are able to form letters in an alphabetic system and can copy and produce isolated, basic strokes in languages that use syllabaries or characters. Given adequate time and familiar cues, they can reproduce from memory a very limited number of isolated words or familiar phrases, but errors are to be expected.

Back to Top

 

Copyright © 2004 Language Testing International. All rights reserved.